Question:
Do you think its about time us Linux users called a truce for the greater purpose?
1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Do you think its about time us Linux users called a truce for the greater purpose?
Nine answers:
inclusive_disjunction
2008-05-23 21:37:41 UTC
I've long since reached a zen-like state where I don't advocate one distro over another. I read what the person is looking for (they actually have no idea), and I recommend several of the more popular ones, and recommend that they try them all. If I were to recommend just one, and the person didn't like it, they would think "If the best distro sucks, the others must be horrible" and they would be turned off from Linux completely. I didn't like the first distro I tried (Freespire), but I knew there were other distros available, so I kept looking (and still look). I have three computers with three different distros, and each one serves their purpose very well.
M M M
2008-05-24 02:06:38 UTC
I didn't realize the Linux users were fighting!





But I would agree that which distro is "best" is purely subjective. I have tried 15 or 20 different distros and found them all fascinating. Some I liked, some I didn't.



Where do I sign the Peace Treaty?



Signed,

MMM (VraiChevalier)
Astro
2008-05-23 23:46:37 UTC
Yes- (answer..)

Wow, I hope ya'll don't mind me stopping by. Whew! Hope the Linux crowd on YA sees this thread. I agree/appreciate ALL the posts seen here. Point and counter. Won't pretend to have the level of understanding, you guys hold in Linux, but I am passionate about it. I read quite a bit daily, so I can understand the history, current affairs, offerings, & the politics involved. People develope a 'taste' toward a certain flavor. Me, the same. Healthy debate is good for the spirit, but is hard on the audience. Ya'll certainly don't need my tacit approval, but I'll offer it just the same. I support Linux as a way to be free from the shackles of those who would bind us to their 'way' of electronic life. I try to come off as a bit flipant, but I can be serious. Well, unless its answering Steves questions... hee hee hee.... When I see a post on Linux, theres a very small group I am anxious to see if they've made a response yet. Guess who they are?
2008-05-23 22:32:11 UTC
Yeah...



And I sign, Snakeyes:



Steve
freebsd-unix.sg
2008-05-24 14:43:36 UTC
With all due respect i think u are missing a point

See Linux isn't a camp there is no truce thing

Or best disto thing

Each Linux distro is tuned or tweak to do a particular purpose

Eg. Backtrack Linux is the collection of network security testing aka Cracking

Fedora Debian OpenSUSE Ubuntu target Desktop users

Red Hat which is commercially supported targets companies

See there is no BEST it is just which one is yr taste

Anyway I exited the Linux Camp (ex Ubuntu then Debian)

because i realised they are too purist on GPL licensing

I like BSD because of their 4 clause license (search for it)

Also like Linux

BSD have different Distro for different purpose

OpenBSD = Security

NetBSD = Portability and Compact

FreeBSD = Original

PC-BSD = Desktop User

So I don't there is a need for truce because specialization is good

Also reasons i switch to BSD:

BSD pioneered the Internet

I hate penguins especially silly ones like tux

gentoo is much better

Yahoo and many others runs on BSD

Many Heavy traffic Server runs on BSD

Any there is this interesting picture below

To Linux users: Plz do not kill me after seeing this i just provided the link

You can also search Beastie come tux in google images
2008-05-24 05:34:21 UTC
yeah sure lol



signed



Answer Master





EDIT:



Ahahahahahah This is a new one ---Linux vs BSD!
jplatt39
2008-05-23 22:39:09 UTC
I REALLY don't think you will like my answer. Back in the eighties when, ten years after the rest of my family I started getting interested in computers, there were three types of Computer Users. MacUsers (a.k.a. MacFascists) were usually well heeled and had BFA's or Humanities degrees. As far as they were concerned, the rest of us were barbarians. MS-DOS users were a catchall group I should probably mention last, but I have a point in this. On the one hand MS-DOS had, at the time IBM behind it and IBM was trusted by the suits. On the other hand one advantage it had over the Macintosh was it was more open to direct access to the hardware, which was fairly standard, so things were both faster and more reliable than on the Macintosh (though the latter was the machine with the GUI). Finally there were the Unix geeks. Hands down, these were the most arrogant people I knew. One of them ACTUALLY YELLED AT ME for doing a drawing in his presence with burnt match sticks. I should have gotten some "real" art supplies. Dork. (admittedly I only have a BA in fine arts, not the tougher BFA). They for the most part knew what you use a computer for, they said -- and this and that. Even the computer press said that Unix geeks were more arrogant than the rest of us and I believed it.



With Windows, of course, Redmond proved that they felt they knew what you use a computer for, and were and are determined to control it. The Olympics will be available on the Internet here in the US only if you have Silverlight installed. When someone on GrokLaw commented on that and added Adobe was safer to play footsie with -- meaning their products involve vendor lock-in too, all I could think of and I commented on was that with their contracts with various commercial printing companies like Pantone, the difference was with Microsoft you were locked into one vendor, with Adobe, at least three, maybe more. He seemed to think I was criticizing him. I'm really just horrified by what Microsoft is doing to our installed knowledge base as they try to replace EVERYONE's standards with their own.



Jobs went into exile for a while to NeXT computers, and returned to spread the gospel of Unix at Apple, and a subset of Unix geeks came up with Linux, which over the last fifteen years has become the last resort for everyone else. Ubuntu Linux is an Ubuntu gesture. dyne:bolic is RASTA software, and the National Security Agency has come up with SELinux -- while Red Hat/Fedora has become something very strange I don't necessarily think should be compared to other distros.



I'm sorry to have to tell you this but Linux is a transmongrified Unix. It fulfills the same function MS-DOS used to play in the eighties, yes, but in essence it was designed by and for engineers and the consumer modifications are merely ONE development of this.



And the Old Unix Geeks are still around. And they still have their opinions about what makes sense from an engineering point of view (and some of them use ball point pens. Yuck).



We aren't going to settle these arguments and we aren't going to supress them without disrespecting people who DO deserve our UTMOST respect if not agreement. Donald Knuth recently revealed he mainly uses an Ubuntu notebook.



So no. No truce. vi against emacs, Gnome vs. KDE and for that matter the console vs. GUI (console RULZ). And of course Novell paid Miguel de Icaza to put that HORRIBLE Mono in Gnome. You walk into most Linux User Group meetings and you won't hear many arguments -- Novell made a deal with the Devil and we should boycott OpenSuse. This is probably being READ by OpenSuse users.



The differences will not go away, and suppressing them will cause more harm and disrespect than good.



EDIT: I stand by this answer. The past is STILL HERE. WHO ARE YOU TO TELL IT TO SHUT UP?
2008-05-24 00:02:36 UTC
ive used linux before, the interface is more like windows, but i sure do like windows way much better.

i use Microsoft Windows Xp Pro.

of course i used a mac Before too.

i am just more of a windows person, since i am used to XP's user interface.
2008-05-23 14:42:07 UTC
Peace Treaty :)



Conditions:



1. No making fun of Ubuntu.

2. Only insult Microsoft Windows.

3. Recommend a variety of distros for new users wanting to try linux.

4. Provide support to all distro users.



By signing this treaty u agree that u will not fight amongst yourselves and all distros will be considered equal whether they r or not. You will also admit that opensuse is best distro on earth...lol.



If at anytime before 4 months this treaty is broken, the punishment is the electric chair.



Please sign besides your name:



I will sign after u ;)



Edit:



Lol....why won't u admit suse is the best?



Fine we can agree but I will only sign after u :)



We still have to make the rest of our contacts sign lol



Edit 2



We r going to make them an offer they can't refuse.



Either their brains or their signature will be on this treaty....lol.



I agree to the terms, now only if everyone signed it :)



Edit 3:



Lol thanks, I was joking though u know, the treaty and stuff is all kind of a joke but I agree with u 100% that we should all stop fighting.



Lets get everyone else to sign it as well.



Edit 4:



To the answerer after Steve, if u want to boycott Novell or openSUSE then its safe to say u can stop using linux cause Novell sponsors, funds and provides code to everything that linux has, KDE 4 new kick off menu was designed by Novell and we opensuse users had it since opensuse 10.2.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...